Putting an employee on a PIP wasn’t FMLA interference, one court ruled

November 18, 2026

Did the employer fire Charles because of his poor job performance, or because he took leave under the federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA)? A court said it was the job performance and granted the employer’s request to have the case dismissed.

The story

Charles, a manager, performed well for the company for a few years. However, his job performance rating for 2022 was lower than usual. One of the issues involved not taking accountability for his team’s work.

In early 2023, his boss decided to put Charles on a performance improvement plan (PIP).

On March 1, Charles told his boss that his wife was expecting a child and that he planned to take leave when the baby was born and again during the holidays. This was the first time Charles mentioned this.

At a meeting on March 3, his boss told Charles that he would be placed on a PIP.

On May 22, the PIP period ended, but it hadn’t gone smoothly. Charles wouldn’t have succeeded during the PIP without a lot of guidance. Then, Charles took leave from June 30 through August 15 after the baby was born.

One of Charles’ projects was supposed to launch in mid-July, but it didn’t due to a major glitch that no one on his team caught. The project finally launched in September, but the delay cost the company more than $140,000. After reviewing all the facts involved, including the documented evidence of Charles’ poor job performance, the employer fired Charles on October 10.

The suit

Charles sued, arguing that the employer interfered with his FMLA rights by firing him — because his termination both effectively denied him reinstatement to his pre-leave position and prevented him from taking the second half of his planned intermittent leave. He also claimed the employer retaliated against him for exercising his FMLA rights.

The employer argued that Charles was fired because he had been on a PIP and immediately afterward, he had egregiously failed to fulfill the basic goals, requirements, and deliverables of his position.

The ruling

Charles tried to argue that the employer placed him on a PIP on March 3, 2023, just 2 days after he first told his boss that his wife was pregnant. But the court pointed out that his boss decided to put him on a PIP at least 1 month earlier and began drafting the PIP around that time. So, the PIP timing wasn’t an issue.

Charles was fired a few months after he went on leave, and 1 month after he returned from leave, so he also tried to argue that the timing showed interference or retaliation. But, said the court, the timing was insufficient in light of the evidence of Charles’ poor job performance.

The court agreed with the employer that:

  • Charles couldn’t show that his termination was FMLA interference; and
  • Even if Charles had been able to show this, the employer fired him for a legitimate reason, and Charles couldn’t show that this reason was pretextual.

The employer’s strong documentation of Charles’ poor job performance helped save the day in court.

Sparks v. The New York Times Company, Southern District of New York, No. 1:24-cv-00455, August 17, 2026.

Key to remember: Strong documentation that supports a termination unrelated to FMLA leave helped one employer prevail in court.

Court decisions are based on the specific facts presented and each court’s interpretation of the law. Because courts may reach different conclusions, similar situations can lead to different outcomes. Employers should avoid relying on a solitary case as definitive guidance and instead assess each situation carefully, considering applicable laws, and seeking advice when needed.


Publish Date

November 18, 2026

Author

Darlene Clabault

Type

Industry News

Industries

{not populated}

Related Topics

Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA)

Governing Bodies

{not populated}

Citations

{not populated}